Each of these pairs with Nightmare Shepherd in more than one way.
Sacrifices creatures
Nightmare Shepherd rewards creatures dying. Each of these sacrifices creatures. All cards for this theme
- Victimize — Sorcery
- Deadly Dispute — Instant
- Ashnod's Altar — Artifact
- Phyrexian Tower — Legendary Land
- Village Rites — Instant
- Mirkwood Bats — Creature — Bat
- Viscera Seer — Creature — Vampire Wizard
- Diabolic Intent — Sorcery
- Braids, Arisen Nightmare — Legendary Creature — Nightmare
- Phyrexian Altar — Artifact
- High Market — Land
- Warren Soultrader — Creature — Zombie Goblin Wizard
Rewards big creatures
Nightmare Shepherd is a big creature. Each of these rewards big creatures. All cards for this theme
- Reanimate — Sorcery
- Animate Dead — Enchantment — Aura
- Bonders' Enclave — Land
- Portal to Phyrexia — Artifact
- Dreadhorde Invasion — Enchantment
- Sculpting Steel — Artifact
- Necromancy — Enchantment
- Professor Onyx — Legendary Planeswalker — Liliana
- Will of the Abzan — Sorcery
- Junji, the Midnight Sky — Legendary Creature — Dragon Spirit
- Masterwork of Ingenuity — Artifact — Equipment
- Grave Researcher // Reanimate — Creature — Troll Warlock // Sorcery
Rewards tokens
Nightmare Shepherd makes tokens. Each of these rewards tokens. All cards for this theme
- Three Tree City — Legendary Land
- Banner of Kinship — Artifact
- Dreadhorde Invasion — Enchantment
- Nadier's Nightblade — Creature — Elf Warrior
- Glaring Fleshraker — Creature — Eldrazi Drone
- Stridehangar Automaton — Artifact Creature — Construct
- Hero's Blade — Artifact — Equipment
- Swarmyard Massacre — Sorcery
- Abyssal Harvester — Creature — Demon Warlock
- White Lotus Tile — Artifact
- Promise of Aclazotz // Foul Rebirth — Enchantment // Sorcery — Adventure
- Orcrist, Goblin-cleaver — Legendary Artifact — Equipment
Rewards enchantments
Nightmare Shepherd is an enchantment. Each of these rewards enchantments. All cards for this theme
- Nettlecyst — Artifact — Equipment
- Doomwake Giant — Enchantment Creature — Giant
- Grim Guardian — Enchantment Creature — Zombie
- Demon of Fate's Design — Enchantment Creature — Demon
- Helm of the Gods — Artifact — Equipment
- Cacophony Unleashed — Enchantment
- Ashiok's Reaper — Creature — Nightmare
- Balemurk Leech — Creature — Leech
- Crystal Chimes — Artifact
- Agent of Erebos — Enchantment Creature — Zombie
- Shambling Suit — Artifact Creature — Construct
- Damping Engine — Artifact
Rewards Demons
Nightmare Shepherd is a Demon. Each of these rewards Demons. All cards for this theme
- Master of Dark Rites — Creature — Vampire Cleric
- Demonic Counsel — Sorcery
- Ardyn, the Usurper — Legendary Creature — Elder Human Noble
- Demonic Covenant — Kindred Enchantment — Demon
- Blood Speaker — Creature — Ogre Shaman











