Each of these pairs with Midnight Mayhem in more than one way.
Rewards casting spells
Midnight Mayhem is an instant or sorcery. Each of these rewards casting spells. All cards for this theme
- Storm-Kiln Artist — Creature — Dwarf Shaman
- Guttersnipe — Creature — Goblin Shaman
- Pinnacle Monk // Mystic Peak — Creature — Djinn Monk // Land
- Harmonic Prodigy — Creature — Human Wizard
- Dualcaster Mage — Creature — Human Wizard
- Coruscation Mage — Creature — Otter Wizard
- Young Pyromancer — Creature — Human Shaman
- Firebrand Archer — Creature — Human Archer
- Flare of Duplication — Instant
- Fiery Inscription — Enchantment
- Electro, Assaulting Battery — Legendary Creature — Human Villain
- Past in Flames — Sorcery
Rewards tokens
Midnight Mayhem makes tokens. Each of these rewards tokens. All cards for this theme
- Three Tree City — Legendary Land
- Impact Tremors — Enchantment
- Anointed Procession — Enchantment
- Mondrak, Glory Dominus — Legendary Creature — Phyrexian Horror
- Adeline, Resplendent Cathar — Legendary Creature — Human Knight
- Terror of the Peaks — Creature — Dragon
- Ocelot Pride — Creature — Cat
- Cathars' Crusade — Enchantment
- Banner of Kinship — Artifact
- Elspeth, Storm Slayer — Legendary Planeswalker — Elspeth
- Caretaker's Talent — Enchantment — Class
- Intangible Virtue — Enchantment
Rewards gaining life
Midnight Mayhem gains life. Each of these rewards gaining life. All cards for this theme
- Ocelot Pride — Creature — Cat
- The Wind Crystal — Legendary Artifact
- Alhammarret's Archive — Legendary Artifact
- Heliod, Sun-Crowned — Legendary Enchantment Creature — God
- Exemplar of Light — Creature — Angel
- Well of Lost Dreams — Artifact
- Archangel of Thune — Creature — Angel
- Cleric Class — Enchantment — Class
- Ajani, Strength of the Pride — Legendary Planeswalker — Ajani
- Rhox Faithmender — Creature — Rhino Monk
- Elenda's Hierophant — Creature — Vampire Cleric
- Angel of Vitality — Creature — Angel
Is a Gremlin
Midnight Mayhem rewards Gremlins. Each of these is a Gremlin. All cards for this theme
- Taurean Mauler — Creature — Shapeshifter
- Mirror Entity — Creature — Shapeshifter
- Bloodline Pretender — Artifact Creature — Shapeshifter
- Universal Automaton — Artifact Creature — Shapeshifter
- Crib Swap — Kindred Instant — Shapeshifter
- Firdoch Core — Kindred Artifact — Shapeshifter
- Changeling Wayfinder — Creature — Shapeshifter
- Three Tree Mascot — Artifact Creature — Shapeshifter
- Barkform Harvester — Artifact Creature — Shapeshifter
- Blisterspit Gremlin — Creature — Gremlin
- Irregular Cohort — Creature — Shapeshifter
- Scurry of Gremlins — Enchantment







