Each of these pairs with Case of the Pilfered Proof in more than one way.
Makes tokens
Case of the Pilfered Proof rewards tokens. Each of these makes tokens. All cards for this theme
- Smothering Tithe — Enchantment
- Urza's Saga — Enchantment Land — Urza's Saga
- Idol of Oblivion — Artifact
- Academy Manufactor — Artifact Creature — Assembly-Worker
- Anointed Procession — Enchantment
- Helm of the Host — Legendary Artifact — Equipment
- Treasure Vault — Artifact Land
- Adeline, Resplendent Cathar — Legendary Creature — Human Knight
- Maskwood Nexus — Artifact
- Field of the Dead — Land
- Felidar Retreat — Enchantment
- Elspeth, Storm Slayer — Legendary Planeswalker — Elspeth
Rewards enchantments
Case of the Pilfered Proof is an enchantment. Each of these rewards enchantments. All cards for this theme
- Hall of Heliod's Generosity — Legendary Land
- Archon of Sun's Grace — Creature — Archon
- All That Glitters — Enchantment — Aura
- Sphere of Safety — Enchantment
- Sigil of the Empty Throne — Enchantment
- Adagia, Windswept Bastion — Land — Planet
- Ondu Spiritdancer — Creature — Kor Cleric
- Mesa Enchantress — Creature — Human Druid
- Heliod, Sun-Crowned — Legendary Enchantment Creature — God
- Nettlecyst — Artifact — Equipment
- Ethereal Armor — Enchantment — Aura
- Starfield Mystic — Creature — Human Cleric
Rewards +1/+1 counters
Case of the Pilfered Proof adds +1/+1 counters. Each of these rewards +1/+1 counters. All cards for this theme
- Hangarback Walker — Artifact Creature — Construct
- Agatha's Soul Cauldron — Legendary Artifact
- Abzan Falconer — Creature — Human Soldier
- Lae'zel, Vlaakith's Champion — Legendary Creature — Gith Warrior
- Parting Gust — Instant
- Lion Sash — Artifact Creature — Equipment Cat
- The Ooze — Legendary Artifact
- Animation Module — Artifact
- Big Mother Mouser — Artifact Creature — Robot
- Zack Fair — Legendary Creature — Human Soldier
- Scholar of New Horizons — Creature — Human Scout
- Dusk Legion Duelist — Creature — Vampire Soldier
Is a Detective
Case of the Pilfered Proof rewards Detectives. Each of these is a Detective. All cards for this theme
- Mirror Entity — Creature — Shapeshifter
- Bloodline Pretender — Artifact Creature — Shapeshifter
- Universal Automaton — Artifact Creature — Shapeshifter
- Crib Swap — Kindred Instant — Shapeshifter
- Irregular Cohort — Creature — Shapeshifter
- Firdoch Core — Kindred Artifact — Shapeshifter
- Changeling Wayfinder — Creature — Shapeshifter
- Three Tree Mascot — Artifact Creature — Shapeshifter
- Barkform Harvester — Artifact Creature — Shapeshifter
- Wojek Investigator — Creature — Angel Detective
- Merchant of Truth — Creature — Angel Detective
- Selfless Police Captain — Creature — Human Detective











